Aber Prof. Hanning setzt sich hin, definiert 5 Voynich-Zeichen als Vokale, verweist auf EVA, wobei dieser Ansatz schon in sich zu verwerfen ist (hat bis heute keine Lösung hervorgebracht, außer einen Arbeitskreis zu definieren), und beginnt, um einen semitischen Ansatz zu erhalten, diese Vokale aus den “Voynich-Wörtern” zu löschen. Some of the pages are missing, with around 240 remaining. But as I also wrote, and I mean, if you think, “Nebenbei: der Ansatz von Professor Hannig ist bis jetzt der beste, den ich gesehen haben”, I respect that, but would suggest you give it the test I describe above, before committing your reputation on it. Sometimes it is said that the critique who cannot repeat their results is just not expert enough in some field… linguistics, or the specific linguistics necessary “here”. Three letters are superfluous. Thanks for reading. ), modern counterfeiting (variant c) can be excluded with certainty. One scenario would have the manuscript given to Rudolph2 by Rabbi Lowe from archives. They have given themselves so many adjustable values, so many rules to use, then discard, when needed, that there is absolutely no way that another person could ever repeat their results. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. The videos are made by different YouTube users. You are welcome to believe that, but you would be incorrect. We thank you! “Nebenbei: der Ansatz von Professor Hannig ist bis jetzt der beste, den ich gesehen haben.”. But rather than give up, they begin to give some room for “adjustment”: By allowing multiple character values for one Voynich character; and/or give multiple Voynich characters one plaintext value. Please click below to consent to the use of this technology while browsing our site. But rather than that, I would be more interested in knowing if you actually put this to the test, yourself? We first learn the origin of the name: Acquired by Polish bookseller Wilfrid Voynich in 1912, the manuscript passed into the care of his wife Ethel, an Irish artist and novelist, upon his death in 1930. A German egyptologist claims to have deciphered the Voynich Manuscript. “meaning” in a certain sense, with archaic imagery – including the very ancient, which of course includes Egyptian works. Wenn eine Übersetzung sauber funktioniert, dann taucht dieses Problem nicht auf! Diese 64 Seiten von Herrn Prof. Hanning unterscheiden sich im Grundansatz von keinem bisherigen 08-15-Verschlüsselungsansatz. Hi, I don’t make these videos. Its study shares resonances with pareidolia, akin to seeing recognizable shapes in clouds or wood grains, and with the Law of the Instrument, where when your tool is a hammer, everything looks like a nail. Any further nuances past the point of knowing why it fails, as I carefully explained, are moot points. Sometimes this is explained because they have a special “insight”, that is the same as the VMs author, that no one else understands. 4. wie rebellieren in Gegenwart von Propheten Any translation of any work must fulfill both #1 and #2 at the same time: 1) Repeatable: By someone given a lexicon and set of rules, grammar, and/or system of deciphering, translation and/or decoding, must be able to repeat the results of the proposer. I would be interested to know what translation you are comparing this to, then? They have, not any Voynich author. Maybe here, but not there? The language Hannig thinks the manuscript is written in is Hebrew. As mentioned, I’m always supsicous when I hear about a new Voynich solution – I have simply seen too many false ones before. if you like our Facebook fanpage, you'll receive more articles like the one you just read! Which leads to: 2) Meaning? As a related note, Wilfrid himself was one of the best-placed persons to have access to such materials, as he purchased the Libreria Franceshini in 1908, which contained up to a half a million items of every type, including scrap. Also, please include a history of Mantova (Mantua) and Francesco’s cipher relationship to Mantova a scribes that produced these documents. I am deciphering the Voynich manuscript and received a positive result. So to base any judgement on the era and/or authenticity of the work can only be based on a highly variable and speculative assessment of the text and illustrations. But in short, I would say that we know little with “certainty”, most of all those things which go beyond the few “certains” we do know, and into the realm of opinion. These cookies do not store any personal information. The Writing System of the Cryptic Voynich Manuscript Explained: British Researcher May Have Finally Cracked the Code, Has the Voynich Manuscript Finally Been Decoded? ), That’s like (something) that delivers mind. The Voynich Manuscript has been reliably dated to mere decades before the invention of the printing press, so it's likely that its peculiar blend of plagiarism and curation was a dying format. Not a living soul knows what it means. Slightly larger than a modern day paperback, the manuscript contains astrological charts, strange plants, ladies bathing and a script that experts have, as yet, failed to … We find the free courses and audio books you need, the language lessons & educational videos you want, and plenty of enlightenment in between. I don’t mean for the two results to be similar in some ways, or some aspects… nor that they should be “adjusted” after the fact, by comparing and “fixing” your results, and his, to match better. The author of this work, as with many other (so similar it is hard to tell them apart), “The proposer of this solution allows and demands for the reader an infinite amount of speculative latitude”, which then renders any results they offer, useless. Use his “system”, and (multiple, variable) character assignments, and rules, and so on. We first learn the origin of the name: Acquired by Polish bookseller Wilfrid Voynich in 1912, the manuscript passed into the care of his wife Ethel, an Irish artist and novelist, upon his death in 1930. Bigram 750 challenge solved, new world record set. To me, all signs point to an earthly location; as a result, I expect there are savants who will try to distract attention from that conclusion because it is untenable politically: essentially a “pandora’s box” in the full etymologic decryption of that word. The Voynich Manuscript came to light in 1912, after Wilfrid Voynich, a rare books dealer in London, bought the manuscript in Italy. The most famous and most interesting encrypted book of all is, of course, the Voynich Manuscript (#00001 on my list), a 230-pages work surrounded by mystery. ), das ist wie (etwas), das liefert Geist. Wenn es denn eine semitische Sprache gewesen wäre, dann hätte sie Becks damals schon gefunden, was er aber nicht hatte. This is important, because no person meaning to communicate information in the Voynich would practically want two readers to come up with two different results. Maybe this one means this from Hebrew, but that, from Czech, or even Latin, or French? The key to the cipher manuscript placed in the manuscript. … Spoken in Arabic”, And then they note, “As you can easily see from the lack of words and the blurry meaning, not all difficulties have been solved so far.”. The author writes (Google Translation) about, and counters, the fake possibility: “4. „Sicherlich, Nymphaea ist der Zwilling. The manuscript is named after Wilfrid Voynich, a Polishbook dealer who purchased it in 1912. It has been carbon dated to the middle of the Fifteenth Century. // Browning Hi Power Mark Iii, Shut Up, Heather Sorry Heather Riverdale, Marriage Retreat Illinois, Nieuwe Auto Kopen, White Synthetic Shellac Primer Spray, Nieuwe Auto Kopen, 2t Elsa Costume, Where To Buy Masonry Defender, Abbott Pointe Apartments, Congressional Intern Housing, North Ayrshire Restrictions,