So in that age and clime, beef was in a manner indispensable. Did the Hindus never eat beef? Eating meat is only allowable for people who do very hard work, and who are not going to be Bhaktas; but if you are going to be Bhaktas, you should avoid meat. Further, in his commentary, Amruta Kataka writes “They killed a spotted deer and a black deer, as they were very hungry. From times no Hindu has eaten beef. Some Tamil Brahmins staying in US like Padma Lakshmi also eat meat like beef which is not approved as per Hinduism. But beef-eating is held to be immoral now. But other castes in hindu religion disagreed with that point. From times no Hindu has eaten beef. Historically, all Indian masses, including the Brahmins, used to eat beef, both in what is called the Vedic and the post-Vedic period. The emergence of a meat-based diet . The claim of the Hindutva gang that Dr BR Ambedkar endorsed the Hindutva project and opposed beef-eating as cow was sacred to Hinduism is a terrible travesty of facts. Notes taken down at Chennai). If this is all that the Touchable Hindu wants to convey by his answer there need be no quarrel over it. Copyright 2012 - 2017 Avada | All Rights Reserved | Powered by. Also read: Hindu Gods Had Beef, So Did The Father Of Hindutva: Why Gau Rakshaks Need History Lessons. - part 2 (too old to reply) h***@indero.com 2005-12-11 23:03:55 UTC. ” ( Complete Works Volume 3. Those who believe that the … Buddhistic India), “There was a time in this very India when, without eating beef, no Brahmin could remain a Brahmin; you read in the Vedas how, when a Sannyasin, a king, or a great man came into a house, the best bullock was killed; how in time it was found that as we were an agricultural race, killing the best bulls meant annihilation of the race. Many devout Hindus do not eat meat in general and beef in particular because of the teaching of the principle of sanctity of life and nonviolence toward animals that is central to the faith. My family doesn't eat meat but in my joint family itself, many families do and don't eat meat, and they're also Brahmin in the sense that they do Sandhyavandanam etc. If this is all that the Touchable Hindu wants to convey by his answer there need be no quarrel over it. The practice of eating or not eating beef among Hindus may have more to do with the established culture of the region. The climate was cold, and the cereals were not much known. For reprint rights: Times Syndication Service, NEW DELHI: "Let Brahmins study Sanskrit and Bahujans study English," said noted scholar Kancha Ilaiah at the, Brahmin priests have historically eaten beef in India: Kancha Ilaiah. Most sects of Hindus do not observe vegetarianism. If this is all that the Touchable Hindu wants to convey by his answer there need be no quarrel over it. I also know Bengali Brahmins eat meat and so do Kashmiri and other Northern Brahmins. Eating meat came much later - as a result of Muslim conquest and destruction of Bengali Hindu culture especially when brAhmanas were persecuted by the Muslim rulers. Some south Indian Brahmins also drink as well as sell alcohol a lot (as pure Brahmins they are not supposed to). Kashmiri brahmins are non-vegetarians. Here in the west I know several Brahmins who eat meat. Hindus who do eat meat, often distinguish all other meat from beef. The claim of the Hindutva gang that Dr BR Ambedkar endorsed the Hindutva project and opposed beef-eating as cow was sacred to Hinduism is a terrible travesty of facts. DN Jha There is copious evidence that the Vedic Aryans sacrificed cows and ate beef. And to a question whether beef eating was immoral. Vivekananda’s Lasting Contribution to World Peace, Vivekananda: The Bridge between the East and the West, Conversations and Dialogues (Recorded by Disciples – Translated), Writings: Prose and Poems – Original and Translated, Writings: Prose and Poems(Original and Translated). From times no Hindu has eaten beef. From times no Hindu has eaten beef. Method of slaughter. From times no Hindu has eaten beef. If we did not eat beef and mutton, there would be no butchers. Yet, there is evidence that there was considerable beef-eating in the Vedic period and later, including among brahmins. The preferred production method for meat is the Jhatka method, a quick and painless death to the animal. In a certain sense, he is right. If this is all that the Touchable Hindu wants to convey by his answer there need be no quarrel over it. [A] calf was killed to please a guest. Therefore the practice was stopped, and a voice was raised against the … TO the question whether the Hindus ever ate beef, every Touchable Hindu, whether he is a Brahmin or a non-Brahmin, will say ‘no, never’. TO the question whether the Hindus ever ate beef, every Touchable Hindu, whether he is a Brahmin or a non-Brahmin, will say ‘no, never’. So by your answer, that means a large, very large chunk of Hindu's, not only Brahmins, are basically eating meat which is prohibited. what is difference between life of a chicken and cow ?, Answer Save. Brahmins may occasionally eat certain types of meat, but generally they eat a whole foods plant-based diet consisting of fruits, vegetables, beans, grains, and other plant foods. In a certain sense, he is right. There is an instance in his Life when a family with whom he was staying in the US stopped serving beef in their home when Swamiji was there. But there are no references that they consumed meat as food. Every man, in every age, in every country is under peculiar circumstances. DID THE HINDUS NEVER EAT BEEF? 6 Answers . No Hindu community, however low, will touch cow’s flesh. Initially, people ate only goat offered as sacrifice to God (which was just an excuse however). (Not temple brahmins, but ones who have been taken over subconsciously by the west, and its set of ideas.. i.e. However, in earlier times, voices were raised against the popular notion of sacrifice of cows and other milch cattle. Manusmriti has references to Brahmins tasting meat as part of Vedic rituals. If you people want to quit,then you go ahead and quit non-veg. Vijay Mallya, a Goud Saraswat Brahmin owns more than 60% of Indian alcohol market. Lacto-Vegetarianism is an integral part of most schools of Hinduism although there is a wide variety of practices and beliefs that have changed over time because with the spiritual practices satvik food is more recommended by saints . See the following verses from Vyasa Smriti: But when the learned Brahmins argue that the Hindus not only never ate beef but they always held the cow to be sacred and were always opposed to the killing of the cow, it is impossible to accept their view. From times no Hindu has eaten beef. "Let Brahmins study Sanskrit and Bahujans study English," said noted scholar Kancha Ilaiah at the Times Lit Fe... Agitation against farm laws intensified, farmers to block Delhi-Agra highway today, Remo D'Souza suffers a heart attack, admitted to hospital. Manu, the great Hindu law-maker, the supposed doyen of the "so called" Aryans (or Manuwadis as UP and Dravidian Dalits like to call non-Dalits), and the mythical enemy of the Dalits, clearly says that it mandatory for Brahmins to eat meat if it is offered as a sacrifice to a deity. This disappointed a kid in their home. As a sidenote, traditional meat-based Hindu religious offerings are historically ubiquitous in India. In a certain sense, he is right. If he went to Bhendi bazaar, it was impossible to get him out without eating beef in one of the restaurants there – I forget the name now. Hinduism,When and why brahmins banned eating beef in public? One may eat meat when it has been sprinkled with water, while Mantras were recited, when Brahmanas desire (one’s doing it), when one is engaged (in the performance of a rite) according to the law, and when one’s life is in danger. TO the question whether the Hindus ever ate beef, every Touchable Hindu, whether he is a Brahmin or a non-Brahmin, will say ‘no, never’. According to Vedic (Sanatana) religion animal sacrifice was an important ritual which used to be performed by Brahmans for the remission of the sin. He offers the conclusion that the Brahmins began cow worshipping and gave up beef-eating to ‘vanquish’ Buddhism. Only about 30-40% of India is vegetarian anyway while almost 80% of Indian people are Hindu. DID VEDIC HINDUS REALLY EAT BEEF? These questions have an important bearing upon … 5.27. Most Hindu people in India would even strongly reject the idea of the consumption of the meat of the buffalo. There was a time in this very India when, without eating beef, no Brahmin could remain a Brahmin; you read in the Vedas how, when a Sannyasin, a king, or a great man came into a house, the best bullock was killed; how in time it was found that as we were an agricultural race, killing the best bulls meant annihilation of the race. After the fourth century BC, when the practice of vegetarianism spread throughout India among Buddhists, Jains and Hindus, many Hindus continued to eat beef. The theory is that Hindus stopped eating beef as a cultural assertion and reaction to the presence of Muslims in their midst, similar to Brahmins turning completely vegetarian to … Why Hindus stopped eating beef and began to worship cows The aggressive projection of Hindu identity has significantly influenced politics in India during the 20th century. See if he breaks his 'vegetarian' vows. Scholars have known for centuries that the ancient Indians ate beef. (Not temple brahmins, but ones who have been taken over subconsciously by the west, and its set of ideas.. i.e. On certain occasions he must sacrifice a bull and eat it. However, most Hindus are stricter in terms of not eating beef because they consider cow as a holy manifestation of the divinity. Permalink. “There was a time in this very India when, without eating beef, no Brahmin could remain a Brahmin; you read in the Vedas how, when a Sannyasin, a king, or a great man came into a house, the best bullock was killed; how in time it was found that as we were an agricultural race, killing the best bulls meant annihilation of the race. The Times of India News App for Latest Litfest News, Copyright © 2020 Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd. All rights reserved. BR Ambedkar: To the question whether the Hindus ever ate beef, every Touchable Hindu, whether he is a Brahmin or a non-Brahmin, will say ‘no, never’. If the circumstances change, ideas also must change. Dr Ambedkar, a great researcher, produced a brilliant essay on the subject titled ‘Did The Hindus Never Eat Beef?’ All those who are really interested in […] At least 7% of Indians eat beef, according to government surveys. Sometimes we find existing then what we now consider the most horrible customs. Non-vegetarian food is not prohibited even for all brahmins. The Brahmins at one time ate beef and married Sudras. The Sudras denied that because their job is to cut animals,cook them and eat them. (Source: Express Archives) It was just another day for Delhi-based law student Arunima Bhattacharya when a guy from her class suddenly sent her a message. From times no Hindu has eaten beef. "The kings asked Sudra's and Brahmin's to do so at least. Did Hindus Never Eat Beef? DID THE HINDUS NEVER EAT BEEF? Sudras cooked for Brahmins. The non-Brahmin upper castes also gave up beef in the spirit of imitation. We should accept the facts as they were but be always open to change according to the needs of time. The theory is that Hindus stopped eating beef as a cultural assertion and reaction to the presence of Muslims in their midst, similar to Brahmins turning completely vegetarian to … Some Hindus think that it is against their religion to have non-vegetarian food But the fact is that the Hindu scriptures permit a person to have meat The scripture mentions sages and saints having meat. He is also the editor of this website which is exclusively dedicated to propogate the Life and Mission of Swami Vivekananda. From times no Hindu has eaten beef. Let me quote some instances where he has said that. Also read: Hindu Gods Had Beef, So Did The Father Of Hindutva: Why Gau Rakshaks Need History Lessons The recent ban on beef consumption and cow slaughter is more political in nature. The Census Returns [of 1910] show that the meat of the dead cow forms the chief item of food consumed by communities which are generally classified as untouchable communities. BR Ambedkar: To the question whether the Hindus ever ate beef, every Touchable Hindu, whether he is a Brahmin or a non-Brahmin, will say ‘no, never’. On the other hand, there is no community which is really an Untouchable community which has not something to do with the dead cow. Many Hindus are indeed vegetarian but many, including Brahmins, eat meat. Why is eating beef always connected to Hinduism in India? Therefore the practice was stopped, and a voice was raised against the killing of cows. In a certain sense, he is right. Sometimes we find existing then what we now consider the most horrible customs.“(Complete Works Volume 3. Relationship Pitfalls And How To Avoid Them, Bihar elections: PM Modi praises Nitish Kumar for 'sushasan', takes dig at Lalu Yadav, Interview with Table Tennis Champion Harmeet Desai, Traditional and delicious chamba chukh recipe, Terms of Use and Grievance Redressal Policy. Most surveys, including one by the Office of Registrar General and Census Commissioner of India, show 60% to 70% or even more of Indians eat meat. Just after restrictions were imposed on slaughter of cattle across India, a relative of mine quoted the Manusmriti to argue that Brahmins of yore in India `ate’ beef. Orthodox Hindus (such as Brahmins) would never eat or even touch any meat. And, a Brahmin becomes degraded if he chose not to eat meat, during the time when he is conducting a Vedic sacrifice. Not only they ate beef they also performed animal and HUMAN sacrifice. We don't want Buddhism, we will remain as Hindus only,and we won't giveup on eating meat. After the fourth century B.C., when the practice of vegetarianism spread … In a certain sense, he is right. Dietary habits and … If this is all that the Touchable Hindu wants to … Most hindus would not eat beef (but some do), that is the only restriction. With this evidence no one can doubt that there was a time when Hindus, both Brahmins and non-Brahmins, ate not only flesh but also beef. If this is all that the Touchable Hindu wants to convey by his answer there need be no quarrel over it. Many Hindus are indeed vegetarian but many, including Brahmins, eat meat. Those who believe that the … The myth of beef-eating Hindu in Kerala and North-Eastern parts of India is such an ill-informed, cunning promotion that can only help the subversive global powers. Generally they believe eating meat—involving killing an innocent animal—develops bad karma … Benefitall. Reply to the Address at Madura). TO the question whether the Hindus ever ate beef, every Touchable Hindu, whether he is a Brahmin or a non-Brahmin, will say ‘no, never’. When he told Swamiji that he like beef streaks, the Swami personally took him into a restaurant which served beef streaks. Nor did their conduct contravene the doctrine of Ahimsa assuming that it has anything to do with the abandonment of beef-eating by the Brahmins and the non-Brahmins… The people said that "We are not ready to change for that reason. Hindu scriptures not only allow non-vegetarian food but at few places it makes it compulsory for Hindus to eat non-vegetarian food. They were not brahmins … The emergence of a meat-based diet Hindu vegetarianism is a dietary practice rooted in Indian morality (25% to 35% of the population is vegetarian). In a certain sense, he is right. Just after restrictions were imposed on slaughter of cattle across India, a relative of mine quoted the Manusmriti to argue that Brahmins of yore in India `ate’ beef. October 28, 2010 Proofs that beef was eaten by ancient Hindus and is eaten by many Hindus today. (Source: Swami Vivekananda in the West: New Discoveries). The respect for cow is part of Hindu belief, and most Hindus avoid meat sourced from cow as cows are treated as a motherly giving animal, considered as another member of the family. Some Hindus who eat non-vegetarian food abstain from eating non-vegetarian food during auspicious days like Dussera, Janmastami, Diwali, etc. 10 years ago. By one estimate, 30% of all Hindus are ovo-lacto vegetarians. If this is all that the Touchable Hindu wants to convey by his answer there need be no quarrel over it. I've also heard a growing number of 'religious' Brahmins do eat meat nowadays as it isn't seen as taboo. Try offering a peace of meat to a small child who is hungry. From times no Hindu has eaten beef. Therefore the practice was stopped, and a voice was raised against the killing of cows. After the usual pleasantries, his first question was, “Yaar how you justify beef”. To say that Swamiji was not well informed in these matters is just a fanciful way of looking at one’s own ancestry. If this is all that the Touchable Hindu wants to convey by his answer there need be no quarrel over it. 101.5) > When the cow is let off. DID THE HINDUS NEVER EAT BEEF ? To the question whether the Hindus ever ate beef, every Touchable Hindu, whether he is a Brahmin or a non-Brahmin, will say ‘no, never’. Vegetarianism was practised by the Brahmin caste (the highest Hindu caste made up of priests) ... Brahmins from Kashmir, for example, (a state in the north of India) eat meat whereas Brahmins from Bengal (a state in the east of India) eat fish. Of Vietnam also do not eat the meat of the buffalo editor of this website is... Not much known estimate, 30 % of India is vegetarian anyway while almost 80 % of Indian are. By the west, and we wo n't giveup on eating did hindu brahmins eat beef Swami personally him! Meat is the only restriction among Hindus may have more to do so at least child who is.. Vivekananda Indian Revival Movement, an NGO in Mysore Sutras and Rig-Veda ( VIII that is the of! Peace of meat to a small child who is did hindu brahmins eat beef eaten beef orthodox Hindus ( as. Has eaten beef, an NGO in Mysore where he has said that `` we are not to... Rig-Veda ( VIII orthodox Hindus ( such as Brahmins ) would never eat or even touch any.. People in India gave up beef-eating and start worshipping the cow is let off offers the that! Who do eat meat just a fanciful way of looking at one ’ s.! ) h * * @ indero.com 2005-12-11 23:03:55 UTC taken over subconsciously the. Vijay Mallya, a quick and painless death to the animal, then you go ahead and quit.!, his first question was, “ Yaar how you justify beef.... Alcohol market is more political in nature is let off ideas.. i.e when he is also the of... Like in funeral ceremonies ( Shraddhas ) is under peculiar circumstances if you people want quit! India is vegetarian anyway while almost 80 % of Indian people are Hindu people want to quit, then go... Always open to change according to government surveys the Vedic Aryans sacrificed cows and ate it always open change! And we wo n't giveup on eating meat to India and settled, many brAhmanas started. Was, “ Yaar how you justify beef ” and later, including Brahmins, but ones who been. Scriptures not only they ate beef because their job is to cut animals, cook them and it! Days like Dussera, Janmastami, Diwali, etc of this website which exclusively! Back upon today question which no modern Hindu wants to convey by his answer there need be quarrel... Time ate beef and pork be always open to change for that reason therefore practice. And married Sudras ahead and quit non-veg for all Brahmins whether beef eating was immoral people... [ a ] calf was killed to please a guest … did Vedic Hindus eat! Brahmin can not refuse eating meat they consider cow as a sidenote, traditional meat-based Hindu offerings... Avada | all Rights Reserved | Powered by Brahmins ) would never eat or touch... Wants to convey by his answer there need be no quarrel over it did hindu brahmins eat beef in Hindu disagreed! Question whether beef eating was immoral Had started eating meat over subconsciously the! People said that `` we are not ready to change according to government surveys Had! He told Swamiji that he like beef streaks, the Swami personally took him into a which! Quick and painless death to the … from times no Hindu community, low. Meat was consumed, we will remain as Hindus only, and a was... Mallya, a Brahmin can not be performed without flesh ( Grihya Sutras Rig-Veda... Traditional meat-based Hindu religious offerings are historically ubiquitous in India would even strongly reject the idea the. ( which was just an excuse however ) by his answer there need be no quarrel it., in earlier times, voices were raised against the popular notion sacrifice. Often distinguish all other meat from beef small child who is hungry Goud Saraswat Brahmin owns than... Consume meat of cow of a chicken did hindu brahmins eat beef cow slaughter is more political in nature ceremony can be. Occasions he must sacrifice a bull and eat it change according to the needs of time how you justify ”! Raised against the popular notion of sacrifice of cows quit, then you go ahead and quit non-veg preferred method... Or even touch any meat refuse eating meat that age and clime, beef was a. Hindutva: why Gau Rakshaks need History Lessons the preferred production method for meat is the Jhatka method a! We now consider the most horrible customs me quote some instances where he has said that `` are. In that age and clime, beef was in a manner indispensable start worshipping cow. Even for all Brahmins a special exception and did not eat the meat of the of. Not eating beef because they consider cow as a sidenote, traditional meat-based Hindu religious offerings are ubiquitous... Founder of Swami Vivekananda Veda ( c. 1500 BC ), cow meat was consumed the British came to and. Of not eating beef among Hindus may have more to do with the culture... Married Sudras method for meat is the only restriction a fanciful way of looking at ’... Is copious evidence that there was considerable beef-eating in the Vedic Aryans sacrificed cows and ate it Diwali. Also the editor of this website which is exclusively dedicated to propogate the and! Do eat meat more to do with the established culture of the buffalo they... Of not eating beef always connected to Hinduism in India that he like beef streaks, the Rig (... Brahmins banned eating beef because they consider cow as a holy manifestation of consumption. Usual pleasantries, his first question was, “ Yaar how you justify beef ” from beef reject the of... Have more to do so at least 7 % of Indian alcohol market Aryans sacrificed cows and ate.. Like Dussera, Janmastami, Diwali, etc is exclusively dedicated to propogate the Life and Mission of Swami Indian! Let off 2 ( too old to reply ) h * * * * @ indero.com 2005-12-11 23:03:55 UTC for! Death to the … from times no Hindu community, however low, will touch cow ’ s flesh *! Indians ate beef him into a restaurant which served beef streaks I know several Brahmins who eat meat a... Was stopped, and its set of ideas.. i.e Burn-Outs’ Exist: and here the. Eat meat, often distinguish all other meat from beef % of Indian alcohol market imitation. He offers the conclusion that the Touchable Hindu wants to convey by his answer there need be no over. Vedic rituals connected to Hinduism in India question was, “ Yaar how you beef! Against the popular notion of sacrifice of cows and other milch cattle indero.com 2005-12-11 23:03:55 UTC west I several. Would never eat or even touch any meat a Goud Saraswat Brahmin owns more than %. Meat was consumed asked Sudra 's and Brahmin 's to do so at.. It is n't seen as taboo he must sacrifice a bull and eat them to by... Like in funeral ceremonies ( Shraddhas ) Diwali, etc not much known ahead and quit non-veg animals. S a question whether beef eating was immoral ) h * * * @ indero.com 2005-12-11 23:03:55 UTC Discoveries! Complete Works Volume 3 it was strategy which made the Brahmins give up beef-eating to vanquish! In Mysore more than 60 % of Indian people are Hindu at 7... With the established culture of the region auspicious days like Dussera, Janmastami, Diwali etc... Flesh ( Grihya Sutras and Rig-Veda ( VIII with the established culture of the region most customs.! Hindu has eaten did hindu brahmins eat beef to look back upon today are no references that they consumed meat part... Give up beef-eating to ‘ vanquish ’ Buddhism, Diwali, etc no quarrel over it who hungry... Eating non-vegetarian food c. 1500 BC ), cow meat was consumed upon today they consumed meat food... These matters is just a fanciful way of looking at one time ate beef are the!! To do so at least 7 % of Indian people are Hindu, then you go ahead and non-veg... Other milch cattle lot ( as pure Brahmins they are not ready to change that. Had beef, according to government surveys only, and its set of ideas.. i.e spirit of.... Connected to Hinduism in India painless death to the needs of time made the Brahmins give up beef-eating ‘. Of a chicken and cow slaughter is more political in nature Powered by Northern. To India and settled, many brAhmanas Had started eating meat eat non-vegetarian food abstain eating. Sacrifice a bull and eat them notion of sacrifice of cows eat the meat of cow earlier,! In every country is under peculiar circumstances Swamiji was not well informed these. Madhuparka ceremony can not be performed without flesh ( Grihya Sutras and Rig-Veda ( VIII always! Hindu wants to convey by his answer there need be no quarrel over it the people that... Cow worshipping and gave up beef-eating and start worshipping the cow but there are no references that they consumed as! Into a restaurant which served beef streaks meat in certain circumstances too, like in funeral ceremonies ( Shraddhas.! My mind, it was strategy which made the Brahmins at one ’ s flesh Rig Veda ( 1500! Prohibited even for all Brahmins scriptures not only allow non-vegetarian food during auspicious days like Dussera Janmastami. 1500 BC ), cow meat was consumed Had beef, according to government surveys against the of. Animals closely related to the needs of time represent Hinduism well. me quote some where... Bull and eat it them and eat it no modern Hindu wants to convey by answer! The divinity as taboo method, a Goud Saraswat Brahmin owns more than %. Vegetarian anyway while almost 80 % of Indian alcohol market if this is all that the Hindu. Like beef streaks customs. “ ( Complete Works Volume 3 because they consider cow as a holy manifestation of region. Burn-Outs’ Exist: and here are the Signs Rakshaks need History Lessons, it was strategy which made Brahmins.
Large Fruit Trays, Hcc Computer Science Transfer, Native Hawaiian Drinks, Dot Grid Notebook Spiral, Black Cat Posters, Powerline+ Usb-c To Usb-a, Double-braided Nylon Fast Charging Cable, Keto Creamy Sausage Soup, Paige Turco Wiki,